If you’re a dog lover, the thought of getting a second dog may be both exciting and overwhelming. On the one hand, having another furry friend to play with and cuddle can be a joyous experience.

On the other hand, you may feel guilty about “betraying” your current dog, worry about being able to give both dogs enough attention, or feel overwhelmed by the logistics and financial implications of having two dogs.

Fortunately – these feelings are normal and common. Many dog owners experience guilt and doubt when considering getting a second dog. In this blog post, I’ll discuss some of the reasons for feeling guilty, strategies for overcoming guilt, and practical considerations when preparing for a second dog.

I. Making the Right Decision to Get a Second Dog

Before deciding to get a second dog – take enough time to make a thoughtful and informed decision.

Not all dogs are suited to living with another pup, so it’s essential for you to assess your current dog’s personality and determine if they would enjoy the company of another dog.

If you have an elderly or a solitary dog – bringing home a new young puppy with no social skills or self-control could present many challenges for you.

Consider your current dog’s preferences and try to find a second dog that is really a good match. By finding a suitable companion for your dog, you are less likely to experience feelings of guilt or remorse about adding another dog to the household.

II. Reasons for Feeling Guilty

There are many reasons why someone might feel guilty about getting a second dog. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common ones:

  1. Feeling like you’re betraying your current dog.

I am pretty sure you have a close bond with your current dog, the thought of bringing another dog into the family will may make you feel – like you’re betraying your current dog’s trust.

You may worry – your current dog will feel left out – or that you won’t be able to give them the same amount of attention and affection as before.

feeling guilty

Worrying about being able to give both dogs enough attention.

Dogs thrive on attention and social interaction. If you’re worried that you won’t be able to give both of your dogs enough attention, is the reaon why you feel guilty about adding a second dog to the mix.

For sure you will also worry that your current dog will feel neglected or jealous.

  1. Concerns about finances and logistics.

Having a second dog can be expensive and logistically challenging. The cost of food, veterinary care, and other expenses wil rise. You may also worry about how to manage two dogs when it comes to walking, feeding, and other daily outdoor routines.


It’s very common feeling regretful about getting a second canine – many people share these feelings. While it may not be a pleasant experience, there is some comfort in knowing that you’re not alone in feeling this way.

Furthermore – the fact that you’re considering the impact that a new dog might have on your current pet is a positive sign. It shows that you’re thinking about your dog’s emotional health and well-being, which is crucial when introducing a new pet to the household.

III. Overcoming the Guilt

If you’re really feeling guilty about buying a second dog, there are some strategies that can help you overcome these feelings:

  1. Talk to a trusted friend or family member.

Sometimes it helps simply talking through your feelings with someone you trust – this will help you to gain perspective and feel more confident about your decision.

Your friends or a family member may be able to offer you some advice and support – and you van overthink your decision.

  1. Consider also the benefits of having a second dog.

There are many benefits to having a second dog. Dogs are very social creatures, and enjoy having the company of other dogs.

Energetic Dog play

Having a second dog in your home can also provide your current dog with a new playmate and reduce their risk of loneliness and boredom. Having a second dog can bring more joy and love into your and your current Dogs life.

  1. Be proactive about managing both dogs’ needs.

If you’re worried about being able to give both dogs enough attention, it’s important to be proactive about managing their needs.

Make sure you have enough time in your spare time schedule to spend quality time with each of your dogs! If your time is limited – consider hiring a dog walker or a rekiable pet sitter – if you need extra help.

Make sure you provide each dog with their own toys and beds – this is important to reduce any feelings of competition.

Feeling remorseful about expanding the pet family?

  • Maintain a consistent daily routine, which may be as beneficial for your own mental wellbeing as it is for your dogs.
  • Ensure that you spend individual quality time with each dog, and plan adventures that are suitable for the older dog’s abilities.
  • Allow the younger dog plenty of downtime to rest and relax, and create plans that incorporate both dogs.
  • Remind yourself of the reasons why you decided to bring a second dog into your life instead of being sorry for adding another dog to your family.

IV. Preparing for a second dog

You’ve already decided to bring a second dog to your home – there are some practical considerations to keep in mind:

  1. Make sure your current dog is comfortable with other dogs.

Before bringing the second dog into the family, it will be important to make sure your current dog is comfortable around other dogs.

You can test this by introducing your dog to other dogs before.

  1. Choose a dog that complements your family’s lifestyle and personality.

When choosing a second dog, it’s important to consider your family’s lifestyle and personality.

If you have a very active lifestyle and enjoy outdoor activities – you may want to choose a new dog that has a lot of energy and also enjoys outdoor adventures. It woul de unfair if your current Dog is already old and can not accompany you!

But If you have a more laid-back lifestyle, a more relaxed dog may be a better fit. It’s also important to consider factors such as size, temperament, and breed.

  1. Please ensure that there is enough space and resources for both dogs in your home.

Having 2 Dogs can be a big new adjustment ; so it is very important making sure you have enough space and resources for both dogs.

You need to have enough beds, food bowls, and toys for both dogs – there must be enough space for each dog to have their own territory.

two dogs playing

If you live in a smaller space, overthink your decision – whether or not you have enough room for two dogs to live comfortably.

V. What if your dog gets jealous?

Jealousy is a common emotion for dogs, especially when a new pet is introduced to the household. However, there are ways to manage and minimize jealousy between dogs.

One of the most effective strategies is to ensure that each dog receives individual attention and affection from their owner. This can include spending one-on-one time with each dog, giving them their own designated space and toys, and feeding them separately.

It’s also important for you to avoid inadvertently reinforcing jealous behavior. – For instance, if your dog is acting possessive over a particular toy or treat, it’s best not to give in to their demands, as this can reinforce their jealous behavior.

Instead, encourage positive behaviors and reinforce good behavior with treats, praise, and affection. Additionally, it can be helpful to consult with a professional dog trainer or behaviorist, who can provide personalized guidance and support for managing jealousy between dogs.


VI. Conclusion

Getting a second dog can be an exciting and rewarding experience, but it’s normal to feel guilty and overwhelmed about making such a big decision.

Feeling remorseful about expanding the pet family is normal; by talking to a trusted friend or family member, considering the benefits of having a second dog, and being proactive about managing both dogs’ needs, you can overcome feelings of guilt and make the transition to having two dogs as smooth as possible.

When preparing for a second dog, it’s important to make sure your current dog is comfortable around other dogs, choose a dog that complements your family’s lifestyle and personality, and ensure that there is enough space and resources for both dogs.

With careful planning and preparation, adding a second dog can be a wonderful experience for both dogs and their human family.

Categories: Dogs


Marco Heitner

Hello, my Name is Marco. My family has had pets since I can remember. Today we have a large aquarium and, since recently, a four-month old Labrador. I am the owner of this website, and it is my great pleasure to provide helpful knowledge about pets. Our team is constantly working hard to publish well-researched reports here.


Leave a Reply

Avatar placeholder

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

close X

Try The Best Rated Dog Food On Amazon

Ancient grains like grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed are naturally high in fiber and rich in protein. Unchanged for thousands of years, different grains provide various nutrients such as vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and omega fatty acids.